Skip to main content

In the kitchen

By · · Updated · 3 min read

How to Make Paneer at Home: Soft Paneer From Fresh Milk

Soft paneer from a litre of full-cream milk in under an hour: which acid to use, how much paneer to expect, and why it turns rubbery or crumbly.

यह लेख हिंदी में पढ़ें

How to Make Paneer at Home: Soft Paneer From Fresh Milk

Paneer is milk, heat and a little acid. That is the whole recipe, and it takes under an hour. What separates soft, sweet paneer from the rubbery kind is not a secret ingredient but three things: the milk you start with, how hot it is when the acid goes in, and knowing when to stop.

What you need

  • 1 litre of full-cream milk. Buffalo milk gives the most paneer and the softest; cow milk gives a little less and a lighter paneer.
  • About 2 tablespoons of lemon juice, or 1 to 1½ tablespoons of vinegar, mixed with the same amount of water. The whey saved from a previous batch also works, and is the traditional choice.
  • A muslin cloth or a clean thin cotton cloth, a strainer, and something heavy to press it with.

Step by step

  1. Bring the milk to a full boil, stirring now and then so it does not catch.
  2. Turn the flame off and wait a minute or two, so the milk is just below boiling rather than at a rolling boil.
  3. Add the diluted acid a little at a time, stirring gently. The milk will split into soft white curds and a greenish, nearly clear whey. Stop adding acid as soon as the whey turns clear - more acid only makes the paneer harder and sourer.
  4. Pour it into the cloth set over a strainer. Rinse the curds under cold water for a few seconds; it washes out the sour taste and stops them cooking further.
  5. Gather the cloth, twist out the excess whey, and shape it into a flat block.
  6. Press it under something heavy - a pan full of water works - for 30 to 45 minutes for soft paneer, or longer for a firmer block that holds its shape in a tikka.
  7. Cut it into pieces. If you have time, put them in cold water for 15 to 20 minutes; it firms them up without making them hard.

How much paneer to expect

From 1 litre of full-cream buffalo milk, roughly 200 grams. From cow milk, roughly 150 to 180 grams. Toned or skimmed milk gives noticeably less, and a drier paneer, because a good part of what makes paneer is the fat - the reason buffalo milk does so well here is the same reason it sets the thickest dahi.

Can you make paneer from cow milk?

Yes. The method is exactly the same, and full-cream cow milk makes good paneer. It gives a little less from the same litre, because cow milk carries less fat and protein than buffalo milk, and the block is lighter and more delicate. Press it gently and for less time, since pressing too hard is what makes it crumble.

When it goes wrong

  • Rubbery or chewy. Too much acid, or the milk kept boiling after the acid went in. Take it off the heat first, and stop as soon as the whey is clear.
  • Crumbly. Low-fat milk, or pressed too hard for too long. It still works in bhurji.
  • Sour. It was not rinsed, or too much acid went in.
  • It will not split. Not enough acid, or the milk has cooled too far. Warm it again and add a little more. Some heavily processed packaged milk curdles poorly whatever you do.

Keeping it

Paneer made at home has nothing in it to make it last. Keep it in a covered box of water in the fridge, change the water every day, and use it within two to three days.

The whey is not waste

The greenish whey left behind is good for kneading atta, for cooking dal or rice, and for the next batch of paneer. Keep a cup of it in the fridge for a day or two and it becomes the acid next time.

Milk that is just starting to turn sour can go straight into paneer too, as long as it smells sour rather than bad - more on that in keeping fresh milk from turning. We do not make paneer ourselves, but our fresh buffalo and cow milk is what you would want to make it from, delivered every morning across Jalore City.

We describe what we do and what is in the product. Nothing here is medical or nutritional advice, and dairy is not a treatment for anything - if you have a health question, ask a doctor rather than a dairy.

All articles